The mystery of flight MH370: How on earth, with all
our technology, do we lose a giant plane?
Updated @
19:30: Very
little new information has come to light since this story was first published
this morning. Despite some oil slicks and debris being found in the South China
Sea, authorities have confirmed that they didn’t originate from the MH370.
Numerous experts have attested to the Boeing 777′s excellent reliability and
safety record, and puzzlement at how it could vanish from the skies. We still
have no idea how or why the plane disappeared, nor where it crashed. There are
very, very few reasons for a modern plane to suddenly disappear. Read on for
the original story.
Three
days ago, Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 vanished from radar off the south
coast of Vietnam in the South China Sea. 239 people were on board — and at this
point, it is presumed that they have all perished in some kind of disaster. A
massive search and rescue effort involving 40 ships and 34 aircraft from nine
different nations has yet to discover any sign of the missing aircraft. For me,
this is almost incomprehensible: Despite all of the awesome technology that
mankind has developed, it’s still possible for a Boeing 777-200 with 239 people
on board to vanish. For me, it’s mind blowing that all we have to go on
is the plane’s radar signature — and even then, that last radar reading was so
poor that the search area is thousands of square miles of open
water. Surely, given the fact that we can track a damn smartphone
anywhere on Earth down to a few meters, there’s a better way of keeping track
of missing aircraft?
In the
words of Malaysia’s civil aviation chief, the fate of MH370 is “a mystery.” The
Boeing 777 took off from Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia en route to Beijing, was
cruising normally at 35,000 feet… and then disappeared. There was no distress
call. The weather was fine. The plane’s last known position, via radar, was
just south of Vietnam in the South China Sea — which is where search efforts
have been focused so far — but one theory suggests that the plane turned back
just after the last radar ping, meaning the plane could be hundreds of miles
away in the Strait of Malacca. In the absence of any other information, there
is speculation that the plane was target of a terrorist attack.
Flight
path and search area for Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 [Image credit: BBC]
For me,
the most shocking aspect of the MH370 disaster is that we won’t know what fate
befell those 239 souls until we find MH370′s Flight Data Recorder (FDR), aka
the black box. Except for that last radar reading, we have absolutely no
knowledge of the flight at all until we find that FDR. We have no clue what was
said in the cockpit by the captain and first officer — though, seemingly, if
something did go wrong, they didn’t even have time to send a mayday message. We
have no clue if the plane hit a patch of bad weather, or whether it was
hijacked. It really will be one huge mystery until the FDR is recovered — and
there’s a good chance, if MH370 did crash into the ocean, that the FDR will
never be recovered. In the case of Air France flight AF447, which disappeared
off the coast of Brazil, it took two months to locate the wreckage, more than a
year to find the Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR), and the FDR was never found.
The FDR
has an underwater locator beacon (ULB) that will ping for at least 30 days, and
can be detected up to around two miles away, but when you’re talking about a
search area consisting of thousands of square miles, and waters that are almost
a mile deep on average, finding the black box will be no mean feat.
(Read: Worried about black boxes snooping on you? One is in your
car already.)
Do we live in the stone age or something?
Inside a
modern, solid-state Cockpit Voice Recorder. The Flight Data Recorder is very
similar.
So, think
about this for a moment. We live in a day and age where GPS (and other radio
triangulation methods) can track your smartphone to within a few meters, almost
anywhere on Earth. With dedicated, land-based tracking networks, vehicles and
devices can be tracked to within a few centimeters. Even in the absence of
GPS or radio tracking, inertial guidance (dead reckoning) has been accurate
enough since the ’60s to accurately land a nuclear ICBM on the other side of
the planet, or put the Apollo mission into space. (Read: Think GPS is cool? IPS will blow your mind.)
And then
there’s connectivity. On land, there are networks (both commercial and
governmental) that provide data connectivity almost everywhere. Over water is
definitely harder, but satellites do provide pretty good coverage — and yes,
that particular region of Asia is very well covered by communications
satellites. Finally, even if an aircraft is out of satellite/radio coverage,
there is absolutely nothing preventing the airplane from transmitting a really
juicy low-frequency radio signal that could be picked up thousands of miles
away. This is how they communicate with air traffic control, after all.
Why,
then, does a plane like the MH370 keep all of its secrets locked up in a black
box? Why don’t planes constantly transmit all of their black box data, so
that we know their exact location, bearing, altitude, and other important
factors, at all times?
The short
answer is, there’s no good reason.
- By Sebastian Anthony on March 10, 2014 at 7:36 pm

